2233 Shay Avenue, Santa Maria, CA 93458
Single-family home
Sold September 2026
Listing Agent: Emily Armet (DRE #01514027) · Listing Office: Avalon Real Estate · Contact: 805-748-8780 · Bought with: James Gallegos · Century 21 Masters · MLS #NS26168070 · Source: CRMLS
How this sale compares
2233 Shay Avenue sold for $700,000 in September 2026, 0.1% over its $699,000 list price, after 6 days on the market. That works out to $281 per square foot on 2,495 square feet. Across 52 closed sales in 93458 over the last 12 months, the median sold price is $641,000 and the median is $405 per square foot — 44% above this sale's $281.
| Quarter | Closed sales in 93458 | Median sold price |
|---|---|---|
| Q1 2026 | 1 | $685,000 |
| Q2 2026 | 27 | $650,000 |
| Q3 2026 | 24 | $620,000 |
Figures are MLS-reported closed sales (CRMLS); ZIP medians cover the last 12 months. Nalren does not estimate values. Recently sold in Santa Maria · Homes for sale in 93458
About this single-family home
Welcome to this spacious Willow Creek home, offering a fantastic opportunity to create your dream space! With a desirable open floor plan, this large home is ready for its next owner to add a personal touch with their own updated flooring, paint, and landscaping. The inviting living room features a cozy gas fireplace and flows seamlessly into the expansive kitchen, complete with a center island, abundant cabinetry, and plenty of workspace for cooking and entertaining. A dedicated laundry room and generous storage throughout as well as a large outdoor shed add to the home's everyday convenience. Upstairs you'll find four spacious bedrooms, while the downstairs office is currently being used as a fifth bedroom, offering flexible living options for guests, a home office, or multigenerational living. Ideally located in the sought-after Northwest neighborhood, this home is just minutes from Tommie Kunst Junior High, Prescott Park, shopping, and other local amenities. With great bones, an excellent floor plan, and a prime location, this is an exceptional opportunity to build equity and make this home your own.
Listing description from the September 2026 sale, as reported to CRMLS.
Sale history
Recent sales near 2233 Shay Avenue
- 2224 Alco Drive — Sold $754,000 · 5 bd · 3 ba · 2,355 sqft · Aug 2026 · 0.1 mi
- 2342 N Juleston Drive — Sold $780,000 · 7 bd · 3 ba · 2,481 sqft · Jul 2026 · 0.2 mi
- 926 Vista Del Rio — Sold $181,000 · 3 bd · 2 ba · 1,536 sqft · Aug 2026 · 0.2 mi
- 2208 Pullman Avenue — Sold $599,000 · 3 bd · 2 ba · 1,269 sqft · Sep 2026 · 0.2 mi
- 2170 Avenida Redondo — Sold $200,000 · 3 bd · 2 ba · 1,440 sqft · Sep 2026 · 0.3 mi
- 2421 Baldwin — Sold $724,000 · 4 bd · 2 ba · 2,212 sqft · Apr 2026 · 0.3 mi
- 918 Vista Montana — Sold $265,000 · 2 bd · 2 ba · 1,536 sqft · Jun 2026 · 0.3 mi
- 829 Vista Montana — Sold $190,000 · 2 bd · 1 ba · 960 sqft · Apr 2026 · 0.4 mi
MLS-reported closed sales in 93458, nearest first (last 12 months). All recent sales in Santa Maria →
Questions about 2233 Shay Avenue
When did 2233 Shay Avenue last sell?
2233 Shay Avenue last sold in September 2026 for $700,000, according to CRMLS-reported closed sales.
What did 2233 Shay Avenue sell for?
$700,000, 0.1% above the $699,000 list price, after 6 days on the market — about $281 per square foot.
How does that compare to other Santa Maria sales?
52 homes closed in ZIP 93458 over the last 12 months at a median of $641,000 ($405 per square foot). This sale was $281 per square foot.
Is 2233 Shay Avenue for sale now?
2233 Shay Avenue is not currently listed on the MLS. Browse current homes for sale in Santa Maria on Nalren.