Back to Search Nalren

Sold for $700,000 · Sep 2026

SOLD

Listed at $699,000

Sold

2233 Shay Avenue, Santa Maria, CA 93458

Santa Maria, CA

MLS# NS26168070

2,495 Sq Ft • Single Family Home5bd • 3ba
6 days on market

Listing Agent

Emily Armet

Listing Agent

Avalon Real Estate

DRE #: 01514027

Brokerage: Avalon Real Estate

Property Details

5

Bedrooms

3

Bathrooms

2,495 sqft

Square Feet

2004

Year Built

4,792 sqft

Lot Size

$281

Price/Sq Ft

2

Garage Spaces

N/A

HOA

Single Family Home

Property Type

Description

Welcome to this spacious Willow Creek home, offering a fantastic opportunity to create your dream space! With a desirable open floor plan, this large home is ready for its next owner to add a personal touch with their own updated flooring, paint, and landscaping. The inviting living room features a cozy gas fireplace and flows seamlessly into the expansive kitchen, complete with a center island, abundant cabinetry, and plenty of workspace for cooking and entertaining. A dedicated laundry room and generous storage throughout as well as a large outdoor shed add to the home's everyday convenience. Upstairs you'll find four spacious bedrooms, while the downstairs office is currently being used as a fifth bedroom, offering flexible living options for guests, a home office, or multigenerational living. Ideally located in the sought-after Northwest neighborhood, this home is just minutes from Tommie Kunst Junior High, Prescott Park, shopping, and other local amenities. With great bones, an excellent floor plan, and a prime location, this is an exceptional opportunity to build equity and make this home your own.

Listing description from the September 2026 sale, as reported to CRMLS.

Facts & Features

Details

Stories
2
Cooling
CentralAir
Heating
Central
View
Neighborhood

Sale history for 2233 Shay Avenue

1 recorded sale

$700,000
Sold September 2026 · listed $699,000, on market August 2026, 6 days on market · MLS #NS26168070 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Emily Armet · Listing Office: Avalon Real Estate · Contact: 805-748-8780 · Bought with: James Gallegos · Century 21 Masters

How this sale compares

2233 Shay Avenue sold for $700,000 in September 2026, 0.1% over its $699,000 list price, after 6 days on the market. That works out to $281 per square foot on 2,495 square feet. Across 63 closed sales in 93458 over the last 12 months, the median sold price is $625,000 and the median is $403 per square foot, 43% above this sale's $281.

$281
This sale, per sq ft
$403
93458 median per sq ft (12 mo)
$625,000
93458 median sold price (12 mo)
63
Closed sales in 93458 (12 mo)
6
Days on market
+0.1%
Sold vs. list price
QuarterClosed sales in 93458Median sold price
Q1 20261$685,000
Q2 202625$645,000
Q3 202628$610,000
Q4 20269$570,000

Figures are MLS-reported closed sales (CRMLS); ZIP medians cover the last 12 months. Nalren does not estimate values. Recently sold in Santa Maria · Homes for sale in 93458

Recent sales near 2233 Shay Avenue

Closed sales reported in 93458, nearest first, last 12 months. All recent sales in Santa Maria →

Explore Santa Maria