Back to Search Nalren

Sold for $2,750,000 · Oct 2025

SOLD

Listed at $2,850,000

Sold

1870 Alrita Street, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401

San Luis Obispo, CA

MLS# SC25198089

4,590 Sq Ft • Single Family Home5bd • 5ba
15 days on market

Listing Agent

Randy Steiger

Listing Agent

RE/MAX Success

DRE #: 01084549

Brokerage: RE/MAX Success

Property Details

5

Bedrooms

5

Bathrooms

4,590 sqft

Square Feet

1963

Year Built

1.07 acres

Lot Size

$599

Price/Sq Ft

4

Garage Spaces

N/A

HOA

Single Family Home

Property Type

Description

Your Spanish oasis beckons! As you enter the garden gates of this one-of-a-kind villa, a lush private courtyard with water fountain greets you. This is an excellent space for entertaining, with koi pond, gentle water wall, gas firepit, and lush green foliage on the banks of the year-round creek (Blue Line; with water rights). All of this is a refreshing introduction to the iconic Spanish style home with approximately 3,935 square feet of flexible living space. Four bedrooms (1 set up as an office) and 3 1/2 baths. Enter into an elegant foyer which welcomes you in the heart of the home: The great room with a fireplace at either end, polished wood flooring, outdoor veranda, sitting nook, large dining area, amazing kitchen, all offering views over the city and surrounding hills. One flight up is the primary retreat with large southwest facing deck, corner fireplace, and elegant ensuite bathroom. Heading downstairs from the primary suite you'll find two more bedrooms, a library nook, full bath, and hardwood floors. These bedrooms have beautiful views to the west. Moving down a few more stairs brings you to the wine cellar and family room area with another bedroom and full bathroom. This area would make an excellent guest suite. There are two large double garages accessible from the house, with a combined garage space of 1,176 sq. ft. The separate guest house is also accessed off the main courtyard; featuring one bedroom, one full bath, kitchen, and living room. This space totals 624 sq. ft. A lovely deck provides relaxation, enhanced by the sound of the adjacent creek. Fenced yard areas on the lower part of the lot for pets, gardens, etc. Adjacent and undeveloped 3 acre parcel is also available for purchase separately.

Listing description from the October 2025 sale, as reported to CRMLS.

Facts & Features

Details

Cooling
None
Heating
ForcedAir
View
CityLights, Hills, Mountains, Neighborhood, Panoramic

Sale history for 1870 Alrita Street

2 recorded sales

$2,750,000
Sold October 2025 · listed $2,850,000, on market September 2025, 15 days on market · MLS #SC25198089 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Randy Steiger · Listing Office: RE/MAX Success · Contact: 805-748-0225 · Bought with: Graeme Baldwin · Keller Williams Realty Central Coast
$950,000
Sold June 2012 · listed $925,000, on market February 2012, 65 days on market · MLS #PI184194 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Ken Taylor · Listing Office: Century 21 Hometown Realty PB · Contact: 805-773-2100 · Bought with: Randy Steiger · RE/MAX Del Oro

How this sale compares

1870 Alrita Street sold for $2,750,000 in October 2025, 3.5% under its $2,850,000 list price, after 15 days on the market. That works out to $599 per square foot on 4,590 square feet. Across 263 closed sales in 93401 over the last 12 months, the median sold price is $970,000 and the median is $615 per square foot, 2.7% above this sale's $599.

$599
This sale, per sq ft
$615
93401 median per sq ft (12 mo)
$970,000
93401 median sold price (12 mo)
263
Closed sales in 93401 (12 mo)
15
Days on market
−3.5%
Sold vs. list price
QuarterClosed sales in 93401Median sold price
Q1 202619$1,129,000
Q2 2026114$1,045,000
Q3 202695$960,000
Q4 202635$790,544

Figures are MLS-reported closed sales (CRMLS); ZIP medians cover the last 12 months. Nalren does not estimate values. Recently sold in San Luis Obispo · Homes for sale in 93401

Recent sales near 1870 Alrita Street

Closed sales reported in 93401, nearest first, last 12 months. All recent sales in San Luis Obispo →

Explore San Luis Obispo