Back to Search Nalren

Sold for $1,563,000 · Oct 2025

SOLD

Listed at $1,595,000

Sold

428 S Orange Street, Orange, CA 92866

Orange, CA

MLS# PW25173746

1,558 Sq Ft • Single Family Home2bd • 2ba
9 days on market

Listing Agent

Daniel Slater

Listing Agent

Orange Realty, Inc.

DRE #: 00815061

Brokerage: Orange Realty, Inc.

Property Details

2

Bedrooms

2

Bathrooms

1,558 sqft

Square Feet

1888

Year Built

6,300 sqft

Lot Size

$1,003

Price/Sq Ft

1

Garage Spaces

N/A

HOA

Single Family Home

Property Type

Description

This HISTORIC 1888 VICTORIAN IN OLD TOWNE ORANGE will take your breath away! Believed to be the second oldest home in Orange, it has been METICULOUSLY and SENSITIVELY RESTORED, yet CONTAINS ALL OF THE MODERN CONVENIENCES! In addition to the 1558 sq. ft. in the main home, a SEPARATE GUEST HOUSE/HOME OFFICE/HOBBY ROOM/POSSIBLE ADU provides a 3RD BATHROOM and ADDITIONAL SQUARE FOOTAGE! You’ll immediately be impressed by the INVITING FRONT PORCH and the numerous STAINED GLASS WINDOWS. 10 FOOT CEILINGS, PERIOD LIGHT FIXTURES and ORIGINAL DOUGLAS FIR FLOORING highlight most downstairs living areas. The attractive floor plan includes a FORMAL ENTRANCE FOYER, SEPARATE LIVING ROOM, WONDERFUL SEPARATE FORMAL DINING ROOM highlighted by a WOOD (or gas) BURNING FIREPLACE with CUSTOM MANTLE, a LARGE, COMPLETELY REMODELED KITCHEN that’s a “CHEF’S DREAM,” BREAKFAST AREA, DEN, SPACIOUS MASTER BATH with SEPARATE SHOWER, CLAW FOOT TUB and GORGEOOUS VANITY and INDOOR LAUNDRY ROOM! There’s a WALK-IN BASEMENT for extra storage. An OVERSIZED 1 CAR GARAGE has an EV charger and easy alley access. Set among the lush grounds are a CHARMING GAZEBO and fantastic POTTING SHED. NUMBEROUS FRUIT TREES include avocado, apple, orange, mandarin orange, lemon and lime. The home is also ON THE MILLS ACT, which should make property taxes for the proud new owner about $3000/year, providing huge savings! This home is only a 3 block walk to the HISTORIC PLAZA, with its many restaurants and amenities, including library, train station and the popular HILBERT MUSEUM!

Listing description from the October 2025 sale, as reported to CRMLS.

Facts & Features

Details

Stories
2
Cooling
CentralAir
Heating
Central

Sale history for 428 S Orange Street

2 recorded sales

$1,563,000
Sold October 2025 · listed $1,595,000, on market August 2025, 9 days on market · MLS #PW25173746 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Daniel Slater · Listing Office: Orange Realty, Inc. · Contact: danslater@danslater.com · Bought with: Debbie Miller · First Team Real Estate
$825,000
Sold October 2015 · listed $869,900, on market July 2015, 70 days on market · MLS #PW15160718 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Albert Ricci · Listing Office: Ricci Realty · Contact: 714-633-3600 · Bought with: Charlene Berends · Realty One Group Inc

How this sale compares

428 S Orange Street sold for $1,563,000 in October 2025, 2.0% under its $1,595,000 list price, after 9 days on the market. That works out to $1,003 per square foot on 1,558 square feet. Across 47 closed sales in 92866 over the last 12 months, the median sold price is $1,125,000 and the median is $740 per square foot, 26% below this sale's $1,003. 2-bedroom rentals in 92866 currently list at a median of $3,400 a month (3 listings).

$1,003
This sale, per sq ft
$740
92866 median per sq ft (12 mo)
$1,125,000
92866 median sold price (12 mo)
47
Closed sales in 92866 (12 mo)
9
Days on market
−2.0%
Sold vs. list price
QuarterClosed sales in 92866Median sold price
Q1 20263$820,000
Q2 202617$1,220,000
Q3 202618$1,180,000
Q4 20269$930,000

Figures are MLS-reported closed sales (CRMLS); ZIP medians cover the last 12 months. Nalren does not estimate values. Recently sold in Orange · Homes for sale in 92866

Recent sales near 428 S Orange Street

Closed sales reported in 92866, nearest first, last 12 months. All recent sales in Orange →

Explore Orange