4
Bedrooms
Sold for $1,188,000 · Sep 2025
SOLDListed at $1,295,000
5021 Heyer Ave, Castro Valley, CA 94552
Castro Valley, CA
MLS# 41099331
2,290 Sq Ft • Single Family Home4bd • 2ba
87 days on market
Listing Agent
Sue Fredrickson
Listing Agent
Christie's Int'l RE Sereno
DRE #: 01860800
Brokerage: Christie's Int'l RE Sereno
Property Details
2
Bathrooms
2,290 sqft
Square Feet
1973
Year Built
7,800 sqft
Lot Size
$519
Price/Sq Ft
2
Garage Spaces
N/A
HOA
Single Family Home
Property Type
Description
PRICE IMPROVEMENT OF $100,000 FOR THIS REFRESHED SINGLE-FAMILY GEM IN UPPER CASTRO VALLEY! Step into comfort & endless potential in this updated home, nestled in one of Castro Valley’s most sought-after neighborhoods. Bursting with natural light, this spacious 4 BR, 2 BA residence is freshly painted inside & out; & features brand new carpeting in the bedrooms & hallway & rich engineered wood flooring throughout the main living spaces. Enjoy moving right in with Section 1 clearance, a clear roof report & 20 year sewer compliance. The flexible layout offers a downstairs bed & bath – ideal for a primary or guest suite or home office The airy living room opens to views of the hills & flows effortlessly into a kitchen/dining/family room combo--perfect for entertaining & everyday living. Sliders open to your private back Trex deck. A generous 2-car garage & extra storage throughout ensures you have room for everything! A second side driveway has potential for an RV or boat. Located near top rated CV schools, scenic walking trails, community tennis courts & pool, this home offers easy access to BART, the 238/580 corridor & vibrant shopping & dining in the nearby Central Business District. This is more than a home -- it is an investment in lifestyle, community & family!
Listing description from the September 2025 sale, as reported to CRMLS.
Facts & Features
Details
- Stories
- 2
- Cooling
- WholeHouseFan
- Heating
- ForcedAir, Solar
- View
- Hills
Natural Hazard Information
Earthquake data is shown from a real public source (USGS)
Loading hazard data...
Sale history for 5021 Heyer Ave
1 recorded sale
$1,188,000
Sold September 2025 · listed $1,295,000, orig. $1,395,000, on market June 2025, 87 days on market · MLS #41099331 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Sue Fredrickson · Listing Office: Christie's Int'l RE Sereno · Contact: 925-251-2500 · Bought with: Danielle Keil · KW Advisors East Bay
How this sale compares
5021 Heyer Ave sold for $1,188,000 in September 2025, 8.3% under its $1,295,000 list price, after 87 days on the market. It was first listed at $1,395,000. That works out to $519 per square foot on 2,290 square feet. Across 40 closed sales in 94552 over the last 12 months, the median sold price is $1,536,500 and the median is $711 per square foot, 37% above this sale's $519.
$519
This sale, per sq ft
$711
94552 median per sq ft (12 mo)
$1,536,500
94552 median sold price (12 mo)
40
Closed sales in 94552 (12 mo)
87
Days on market
−8.3%
Sold vs. list price
| Quarter | Closed sales in 94552 | Median sold price |
|---|---|---|
| Q1 2026 | 1 | $1,400,000 |
| Q2 2026 | 22 | $1,510,000 |
| Q3 2026 | 17 | $1,600,000 |
Figures are MLS-reported closed sales (CRMLS); ZIP medians cover the last 12 months. Nalren does not estimate values. Recently sold in Castro Valley · Homes for sale in 94552
Recent sales near 5021 Heyer Ave
Sold $1,450,000SOLD4bd3ba1,970 sqft20044 Shadow Creek CirSold Apr 2026 · 0.5 miKW Advisors East Bay | DRE #01872321Buyer's agent: Monica Gioukaris, Compass | DRE #02098690
Sold $700,000SOLD0 GreenridgeSold Apr 2026 · 0.6 mi
Sold $810,000SOLD3bd3ba1,626 sqft21917 Nugget Canyon DrSold Apr 2026 · 0.6 miEvolve Real Estate | DRE #01452724Buyer's agent: Yingying Qin, Evolve Real Estate | DRE #02367325
Sold $795,000SOLD3bd3ba1,546 sqft5311 San Simeon PlSold Jul 2026 · 0.6 miRealty ONE Group Future | DRE #01799010Buyer's agent: David Trinh, David Trinh, Broker | DRE #01479514
Sold $1,495,000SOLD4bd2ba1,986 sqft5354 Greenridge RdSold May 2026 · 0.7 miAdams Adams & Morris | DRE #00702647Buyer's agent: Isaac Sanchez, Baycal Capital | DRE #01900450
Sold $1,548,000SOLD4bd3ba2,292 sqft18775 E Cavendish DrSold Jul 2026 · 0.7 miExcel Realty | DRE #01335823Buyer's agent: Flannan Lum, Vanguard Properties | DRE #01406899
Sold $1,515,531SOLD4bd2ba1,834 sqft5531 Greenridge RdSold Jul 2026 · 0.7 mi4 Rivers Realty, Inc. | DRE #01312567Buyer's agent: Martha Park, Better Homes and Gardens RP | DRE #01972274
Sold $1,860,000SOLD4bd2ba1,901 sqft5768 Highwood RdSold Jun 2026 · 0.8 miCompass | DRE #01833889Buyer's agent: Madeleine James, EXP Realty of California, Inc | DRE #02162001
Closed sales reported in 94552, nearest first, last 12 months. All recent sales in Castro Valley →
Explore Castro Valley
CRMLS
MLS# 41099331
Listed: 6/6/2025
© 2026 California Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Based on information from the California Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. as of 9/30/2025. This information is for your personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties you may be interested in purchasing. Display of MLS data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Buyer should independently verify all information.
Listed by: Christie's Int'l RE Sereno
Equal Housing Opportunity
Advertising Broker: Nalren Corp (CA DRE #02423715)
Licensed in the state of California
Nalren Corp (CA DRE #02423715) is the Advertising Broker for this IDX display. We are not the listing broker for this property. The listing broker/agent information is shown above. Contact the listing agent for inquiries.