Listing Agent: Jacqueline Hurst (DRE #01876189) · Listing Office: eXp Realty of California Inc · Contact: (888) 584-942... · Bought with: RECIP · Out of Area Office · MLS #ML82013713 · Source: CRMLS
2
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
1,244
Sq Ft
1971
Year Built
Property
Type
None
Cooling
Central
Heating
$809/mo
HOA
How this sale compares
4425 Clares Street sold for $280,000 in April 2026, 0.4% over its $279,000 list price, after 130 days on the market. It was first listed at $375,000. That works out to $225 per square foot on 1,244 square feet. Across 38 closed sales in 95010 over the last 12 months, the median sold price is $732,500 and the median is $716 per square foot, 218% above this sale's $225.
Always dreamed of owning a home in Capitola? Here's your chance! This affordable HUD home offers an incredible opportunity to live in the heart of Capitola for $300,000 in a 55+ community. Welcome to this inviting 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home nestled in the vibrant heart of Capitola. Boasting a generous 1,244 square feet of living space, this home offers both comfort and potential. Step onto the oversized front porch perfect for entertaining family and friends and enter through sliding glass doors into a bright and open dining area and kitchen. The thoughtful layout features two spacious bedrooms, including a primary suite complete with a large en-suite bathroom, walk-in closet, and private access to the backyard. Outside, you'll find a private backyard space waiting for your personal touch. Whether you're dreaming of a garden retreat, outdoor dining area, or a relaxing oasis, the possibilities are endless. Located just minutes from Capitola Village & shops! HOA fees $469 + $150 (gas, electric, water) + $100 (maintenance, and repairs) + $100 (insurance) totaling $809 Since you own the land, the Co-Op fee in Santa Cruz County property tax 1.1% of the purchase price (divided into 12 months) Please review last two photos for the break down on the fees on the Park questionnaire
Listing description from the April 2026 sale, as reported to CRMLS.
Sale history
$280,000
Sold April 2026 · listed $279,000, orig. $375,000, on market July 2025, 130 days on market · MLS #ML82013713 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Jacqueline Hurst · Listing Office: eXp Realty of California Inc · Contact: (888) 584-942... · Bought with: RECIP · Out of Area Office
$328,300
Sold April 2026 · listed $299,000, on market January 2026, 28 days on market · MLS #ML82030810 · Source: CRMLS
Sold September 2023 · listed $475,000, on market May 2023, 28 days on market · MLS #ML81929597 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Gail LoBello · Listing Office: GL Crown Real Estate Inc · Contact: 831-462-4825 · Bought with: Lizzy Kelly · eXp Realty of California Inc
$375,650
Sold July 2023 · on market July 2023 · MLS #ML81936559 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: John Wunderlich · Listing Office: Wunderlich Realty · Contact: 408-201-4007 · Bought with: John Wunderlich · Wunderlich Realty
$510,000
Sold February 2023 · on market September 2022, 89 days on market · MLS #ML81908226 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Jason Potts · Listing Office: Jason Potts, Broker · Contact: 831-464-9191 · Bought with: Vicki Malandra · David Lyng Real Estate
$175,000
Sold December 2022 · listed $250,000, orig. $299,000, on market April 2022, 121 days on market · MLS #ML81885689 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Vicki Malandra · Listing Office: David Lyng Real Estate · Contact: 831.475.8111 · Bought with: Jamie Manley · Sol Property Advisors
$305,000
Sold October 2022 · listed $220,000, on market August 2022, 20 days on market · MLS #ML81903782 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: D. Leilani Williams · Listing Office: Coastal Life Real Estate · Contact: (831) 345-7912 · Bought with: Gail LoBello · GL Crown Real Estate Inc
$185,000
Sold April 2019 · listed $189,000, orig. $255,900, on market December 2018, 74 days on market · MLS #ML81733026 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Diana L. Rugh · Listing Office: David Lyng Real Estate · Contact: 831.429.5700 · Bought with: Sheila Feddema · Sherman & Boone Realtors
$297,500
Sold December 2018 · listed $299,000, orig. $326,000, on market August 2018, 34 days on market · MLS #ML81719922 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Ted Mendoza · Listing Office: eXp Realty of California Inc · Contact: (888) 584-942... · Bought with: Ronald Ramirez · Realty World RFP Realty
$480,000
Sold September 2018 · listed $475,000, on market August 2018 · MLS #ML81719192 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Thomas Tomaselli · Listing Office: David Lyng Real Estate · Contact: 831.475.8111 · Bought with: Samantha Olden · David Lyng Real Estate
$410,000
Sold April 2018 · listed $420,000, on market January 2018, 13 days on market · MLS #ML81687887 · Source: CRMLS
4220 Trotter Street: Sold $1,680,000 · 3 bd · 2 ba · 1,854 sqft · Jul 2026 · 0.2 mi Jacqueline M Heath, Broker | DRE #02060288 Buyer's agent: Tina Schwendemann, KW Thrive Santa Cruz | DRE #01461468
1925 46th Avenue 71: Sold $449,000 · 1 bd · 1 ba · 665 sqft · Jul 2026 · 0.2 mi Bailey Properties | DRE #01717052 Buyer's agent: Linnette Edwards | DRE #01342728
1925 46th Avenue 169: Sold $610,000 · 2 bd · 2 ba · 990 sqft · Jun 2026 · 0.2 mi Coldwell Banker Realty | DRE #01355536 Buyer's agent: Marley Botelle, Sherman & Boone Realtors | DRE #02242643
1925 46th Avenue 148: Sold $575,000 · 2 bd · 1 ba · 874 sqft · May 2026 · 0.2 mi Christie's International Real Estate Sereno | DRE #01382661 Buyer's agent: Kati Mcnamara, eXp Realty of Southern California | DRE #02234544
4202 Sea Pines Court: Sold $860,000 · 3 bd · 3 ba · 1,422 sqft · May 2026 · 0.3 mi Bailey Properties | DRE #01459135 Buyer's agent: Steff Lutz, Epique Realty | DRE #02046928
4320 Clares Street J: Sold $895,000 · 2 bd · 2 ba · 1,156 sqft · Aug 2026 · 0.3 mi Coldwell Banker Realty | DRE #01945495 Buyer's agent: Aurora Wonder Lowe, KW Thrive Santa Cruz | DRE #01974242
620 Sunset Drive: Sold $890,000 · 1 bd · 1 ba · 457 sqft · Oct 2026 · 0.4 mi
533 Riverview Drive: Sold $1,975,000 · 2 bd · 3 ba · 1,814 sqft · Jul 2026 · 0.4 mi Coldwell Banker Realty | DRE #01455690 Buyer's agent: Troy Hinds, David Lyng Real Estate | DRE #01803325