Get the App

5765 Butter Cup, Avila Beach, CA 93424

Single-family home

5765 Butter Cup, Avila Beach, CA 93424 Sold September 2026 CRMLS
$1,610,000Sold September 2026

Listing Agent: Taylor North (DRE #01936978) · Listing Office: San Luis Bay Realty · Contact: 805-709-1126 · Bought with: Cindy Mattison · Coldwell Banker Realty · MLS #SC26105700 · Source: CRMLS

3
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
2,265
Sq Ft
4,641 sqft
Lot Size
2005
Year Built
Single-family home
Type
2
Stories
2
Garage
None
Cooling
ForcedAir, Gravity
Heating
Canyon, Hills, TreesWoods
View
$63/mo
HOA

How this sale compares

5765 Butter Cup sold for $1,610,000 in September 2026, 4.7% under its $1,690,000 list price, after 112 days on the market. It was first listed at $1,800,000. That works out to $711 per square foot on 2,265 square feet. Across 16 closed sales in 93424 over the last 12 months, the median sold price is $1,175,000 and the median is $706 per square foot, 0.7% below this sale's $711.

$711
This sale, per sq ft
$706
93424 median per sq ft (12 mo)
$1,175,000
93424 median sold price (12 mo)
16
Closed sales in 93424 (12 mo)
112
Days on market
−4.7%
Sold vs. list price
QuarterClosed sales in 93424Median sold price
Q1 20261$1,299,000
Q2 20268$950,000
Q3 20266$1,580,000
Q4 20261$1,200,000

Figures are MLS-reported closed sales (CRMLS); ZIP medians cover the last 12 months. Nalren does not estimate values. Recently sold in Avila Beach · Homes for sale in 93424

Description

Tucked within the exclusive gated and guarded community of Kingfisher Canyon in San Luis Bay Estates, this beautifully designed Spanish-style residence offers refined coastal living in one of the Central Coast’s most desirable neighborhoods. Located in Avila Beach, this thoughtfully designed 3-bedroom, 2 full bath, 1 half bath home combines privacy, comfort, and exceptional indoor-outdoor, low maintenance living. A private front courtyard with mature landscaping creates a peaceful entry oasis. Inside, dramatic ceilings and an exceptional floor plan immediately stand out as you enter through the spacious foyer and look through the living room toward the hillside backdrop beyond the expansive sliding glass doors. Designed for entry-level living, the main floor features an open-concept layout integrating the kitchen, breakfast nook, breakfast bar, dining area, and living room into one inviting space. The large rear deck faces east, capturing beautiful views and extending the living space outdoors. The main-level primary suite offers a spacious walk-in closet, soaking tub, walk-in shower, dual vanities, and private water closet. A half bath, laundry room, and direct garage access complete the main level. Downstairs, two guest bedrooms are connected by a comfortable den/lounge area alongside a full bathroom, creating an ideal setup for guests, family, or flexible living. A large walkout deck opens directly to the side yard, enhancing the home’s seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle. Quality finishes include a Wolf oven, Sub-Zero refrigerator, wood cabinetry, stucco exterior, and classic clay tile roofing. The home has been exceptionally maintained and offers timeless design paired with everyday functionality. Residents of Kingfisher Canyon enjoy approximately 4.5 miles of private hiking trails throughout nearly 1,000 acres of gated coastal landscape. The community is golf-cart friendly with convenient access to downtown Avila Beach, the Avila Beach Golf Resort, and the Avila Bay Athletic Club & Spa. Nearby amenities include Avila Village, Woodstone Market, dining, and everyday conveniences. Known for its charming atmosphere and south-facing microclimate, Avila Beach offers some of the best year-round weather on the Central Coast while remaining just minutes from San Luis Obispo and Pismo Beach. Coastal resort-style living at its finest.

Listing description from the September 2026 sale, as reported to CRMLS.

Sale history

$1,610,000
Sold September 2026 · listed $1,690,000, orig. $1,800,000, on market May 2026, 112 days on market · MLS #SC26105700 · Source: CRMLS
Listing Agent: Taylor North · Listing Office: San Luis Bay Realty · Contact: 805-709-1126 · Bought with: Cindy Mattison · Coldwell Banker Realty

Recent sales near 5765 Butter Cup

Closed sales reported in 93424, nearest first, last 12 months. All recent sales in Avila Beach →

See homes for sale in Avila Beach Open the Nalren App

Explore Avila Beach